Arthur Conan Doyle – The Return of Sherlock Holmes (1905)


Vintage Golden Age Mystery
Just the Facts Category: When — Set in Victorian Era
TBR #125 (72e, 53p)
Date Finished: December 3, 2019

There are many classic stories here, with the first several very familiar, but many unfamiliar ones as well. The writing is very precise and the stories logically told, which is not always the case with more recent pastiches. One forgets how good a writer Doyle was and how good and enjoyable the original stories are.

Just the Facts Golden 2019-12-03

Donald E. Westlake – The Spy in the Ointment (1966)


Vintage Silver Age Mystery
Just the Facts Category: Why — It made a “best of” list
TBR #124 (72e, 52p)
Date Finished: December 2, 2019

When the secretary of a pacifist organization that gets mistaken for a terrorist organization by a gang organized by a criminal mastermind, he then has to infiltrate that organization for the federal government and defeat them before he is caught.

A comedy romp in the midst of the mid-1960s spy craze, Westlake delivers an entertaining story that doesn’t quite live up to some of his other works, such as the Dortmunder comedic crime series that started in 1970. It still made Anthony Boucher’s Best Crime Fiction of the Year list for 1966.

Just the Facts Silver 2019-12-02

Anthony Gilbert – She Shall Die (1961)


Vintage Silver Age Mystery
Just the Facts Category: Who — Lawyer
Date Finished: November 29, 2019

A young woman, Hatty Savage, is implicated in the suicide death of her former boyfriend. Although not charged, the village turns against her. Another young woman reveals that the former boyfriend was going to marry her, and soon invites herself into his aunt’s home and life, but when she is murdered, Hatty faces trial. Enter Mr. Crook eccentric lawyer for the defense.

The main characters here are not very likable, but Mr. Crook arrives eventually and saves things through his engaging personality. The mystery has some twists that help deliver a good surprise ending. Very entertaining.

Just the Facts Silver 2019-11-29b

Ellery Queen – The Black Hearts Murder (1970)


Vintage Silver Age Mystery
Just the Facts Category: What — Color in the title
TBR #122 (72e, 50p)
Date Finished: November 29, 2019

Troubleshooter Mike McCall is sent by the governor to deal with a potential race riot in a mid-sized city in the unnamed state. In the midst of a mayoral campaign between a African-American candidate and a law-and-order (racist) candidate, McCall has to calm the white mob and the Black Panther-like organization, even as the law-and-order candidate is assassinated.

A Richard Deming ghostwritten tale of racial tensions is full of stereotypes and filler with a obvious killer and conclusion. Attempts to add romance (or sex) seem out of place with the serious subject matter. A sad sell-out of the Ellery Queen name for such a by-the-numbers book.

Just the Facts Silver 2019-11-29a

Helen Reilly – The Day She Died (1962)


Vintage Silver Age Mystery
Just the Facts Category: Where — At a Country House
Monthly Key Word: She
TBR #121 (72e, 49p)
Date Finished: November 27, 2019

A winter storm in the New Mexico desert has trapped a number of characters at a remote ranch house, where a wealthy and powerful woman has recently died. Among those trapped are Inspector Christopher McKee of New York Homicide, luckily enough since murder soon takes place.

Despite the seemingly random arrival of all the characters, they all end up being interrelated or connected somehow either in New York or in New Mexico. McKee’s isolation and struggles against nature help, if you can get past all of the coincidences that are required to set the story up.

Just the Facts Silver 2019-11-27

2019 Monthly Key Words 2019-11-27

George Harmon Coxe – Deadly Image (1964)

Deadly Image

Vintage Silver Age Mystery
Just the Facts Category: Who — An Artist/Photographer
TBR #120 (72e, 48p)
Date Finished: November 26, 2019

Jack “Flash” Casey, newspaper photographer, finds himself involved with a blackmail scheme after a stockbroker friend gets framed with a half-naked blonde. Another friend, a fellow photographer now on the skids, has also involved himself in the scheme but winds up dead. Casey has to deal with scheming family members, along with nightclub musicians and mobsters, before he has to reveal it all to the police.

Casey returns here in his final outing minus most of his toughness and pulp beginnings, as little more than a Kent Murdock copy. The plot, too, is fairly nondescript and doesn’t surprise. It is all pleasant enough, but Coxe was coasting on fumes by this point.

Just the Facts Silver 2019-11-26